Lula’s Declarations on Iran’s Nuclear Program Are Irresponsible

By Hotspotnews

A president does not get a free pass to declare settled facts on a proliferation issue when the technical record is the opposite of settled. Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva has repeatedly asserted that Iran neither possesses a nuclear weapon nor has any interest in building one. He presents himself as a personal “witness” on the strength of the 2010 Tehran Declaration he helped negotiate with Turkey and Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, and he compares American concerns to the false pre-war claims about Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction.

That framing is not careful diplomacy. It is an assertion of certainty that the evidence does not support.

Before the June 2025 strikes, the International Atomic Energy Agency had verified that Iran held roughly 440 kilograms of uranium enriched to 60 percent. That material is a short technical step from the approximately 90 percent level used for weapons-grade uranium. By the IAEA’s own metric, the stockpile was large enough, if further enriched, to provide fissile material for multiple devices. No civilian power-reactor program requires uranium enriched to that level. Iran was the only non-nuclear-weapon state party to the Non-Proliferation Treaty producing it at that scale. These were not secret claims invented in Washington; they were numbers published by the IAEA.

U.S. intelligence assessments from early 2025 stated that Iran was not, at that moment, actively building a nuclear weapon and that Supreme Leader Khamenei had not reauthorized the weapons program suspended in 2003. Those assessments also noted that the enriched-uranium stockpile had reached unprecedented levels for a non-nuclear-weapon state. The distinction between “not currently assembling a bomb” and “has no interest and is nowhere near the capability” is large. Lula collapses the two.

Since the strikes, the IAEA has been unable to verify the location, quantity, or status of the remaining highly enriched material. It has expressed growing concern about uninspected sites and the inability to confirm that no material has been diverted. A president who continues to guarantee Iran’s peaceful intentions under those conditions is not offering informed analysis. He is substituting personal diplomacy from sixteen years earlier for present-day technical and verification realities.

Heads of state shape international perceptions. When they declare that concerns are fabricated and that a country with a large stockpile of near-weapons-grade uranium has no interest in a bomb, they reduce the credibility of statements that actually track the evidence. Dialogue and support for peaceful nuclear energy are legitimate policy positions. Asserting that the risks are imaginary is not. Lula’s declarations on this subject have been irresponsible.

Lula #Iran #IranNuclear #IAEA #NuclearProliferation #Brazil #ForeignPolicy #MiddleEast #Trump #NPT

Share.
Leave A Reply

Exit mobile version