Bolsonaro’s Coup Case? Same Playbook as Trump’s Jan 6—Lawfare Gone Wild
March 14, 2025 | By Laiz Rodrigues-Hotspotorlando News
If you squint hard enough, the headlines out of Brasília look like a rerun of Washington, D.C., circa 2021. Brazil’s former President Jair Bolsonaro, the lion of the Latin American right, is staring down a Supreme Court showdown over an alleged coup plot to cling to power after his 2022 election loss. Sound familiar? It should. Swap out the Amazon for the Potomac, and it’s Donald Trump’s January 6 saga all over again—complete with a chorus of establishment types crying “insurrection” while conservatives smell a rat: lawfare gone wild.
The script’s uncanny. Bolsonaro, like Trump, refused to go quietly when the votes didn’t break his way. After Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva eked out a win in ’22, Bolsonaro’s hardcore fans—think Brazil’s own MAGA brigade—stormed the capital on January 8, 2023, trashing Congress, the presidential palace, and the Supreme Court. Echoes of Capitol Hill, right? Now, fast forward to February 2025: Brazil’s Prosecutor General Paulo Gonet drops charges, claiming Bolsonaro led a “criminal organization” to overthrow democracy, complete with wild accusations of assassination plots against Lula and Justice Alexandre de Moraes. Evidence? A hefty 884-page federal police report, witness testimony, and some text messages—soundbites the left’s drooling over, but thin gruel if you ask the right.
Flip the page to Trump’s tale. After losing to Joe Biden in 2020, he railed against “stolen” votes—claims that fueled the January 6 riot. The U.S. deep state pounced, slapping him with charges of inciting insurrection, election interference, and whatever else they could pin on him. Like Bolsonaro, Trump’s a lightning rod: loved by the base, loathed by the elite. And like Bolsonaro, he’s facing a legal meat grinder that smells more like political payback than justice. Both men, both nations—same playbook, different accents.
Here’s where it gets juicy. In Brazil, the Supreme Court’s set to rule on March 25 whether Bolsonaro’s case even goes to trial. The stakes? Prison time for a man already banned from running until 2030. In the U.S., Trump’s dodged the worst—back in power as of January, laughing off dropped cases and a Supreme Court that slapped down state bans. Brazil’s conservatives see the parallel and cry foul: this isn’t about law; it’s about silencing the right. “No proof,” Bolsonaro’s son Flávio thundered on X, calling it an “unconstitutional” hit job. Sound like Trump’s “witch hunt” rants? You bet.
The conservative take—here and there—is that this is lawfare on steroids. Take Brazil’s case: the feds say Bolsonaro plotted to poison Lula and off Moraes, a judge who’s made a career of hounding him. Really? Where’s the smoking gun? Texts and testimonies can be spun any which way, and a police report doesn’t mean guilt—it means agenda. Same with Trump: January 6 was chaos, sure, but pinning it all on him stinks of selective prosecution when left-wing riots get a pass. Both leaders tapped into a raw, populist vein—distrust of rigged systems, media bias, and globalist elites—and now they’re paying the price.
Across the Atlantic, the vibes align. Bolsonaro’s allies, like Eduardo Bolsonaro, have cozied up to Trump’s circle—think Mar-a-Lago meetups and Steve Bannon’s cheerleading. X buzzes with cross-border solidarity: “Brazil’s MAGA moment,” one user posted, while another quipped, “Lula’s DOJ is just Biden’s with samba.” The American right’s watching, too—Trump Media and Rumble even sued Moraes in Florida, crying censorship. It’s a conservative axis flexing muscle, saying, “We see the game.”
But here’s the rub: Brazil’s not the U.S. Bolsonaro’s military ties—6,000 officers in his admin—gave his “coup” whispers more teeth than Trump’s bluster ever did. The January 8 riots weren’t just a tantrum; they camped outside army HQs, begging for tanks. History backs it up—Brazil’s 1964 military coup looms large, a ghost Trump never had. Yet, both flops show the limits: no generals bit, no coup stuck. Democracy held, battered but breathing.
So, lawfare gone wild? Maybe. The left’s cheering—Gleisi Hoffmann of Lula’s Workers’ Party called it a “crucial step” for democracy. Progressives here lap up the same line about Trump. But conservatives, from Brasília to Boise, see a pattern: weaponized courts, shaky evidence, and a vendetta to bury their champs. Bolsonaro’s fate hangs on five judges; Trump’s riding high again. Same playbook, different endings—for now. One thing’s clear: the right’s not rolling over, and this fight’s far from done.
