U.S. Court Case Nears Decision on False Immigration Record Tied to Filipe Martins Detention
By Hotspotnews
A Freedom of Information Act lawsuit in Florida is approaching a key ruling that could reveal who was responsible for a false U.S. Customs and Border Protection entry record used in Brazil to help justify the preventive detention of former presidential advisor Filipe Martins.
The case, Martins Pereira v. United States Department of Homeland Security et al. (No. 6:25-cv-00104), is pending in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida, Orlando Division, before Judge Gregory A. Presnell. Filed in January 2025, it seeks internal DHS and CBP documents related to a record showing Martins entering the United States in Orlando on December 30, 2022—the same day then-President Jair Bolsonaro traveled to Florida.
Brazilian authorities cited the record when ordering Martins’ first preventive arrest in February 2024, treating it as evidence of a potential flight risk. Martins denied ever making the trip. Subsequent Brazilian geolocation data and other records also indicated he remained in the country.
In October 2025, CBP issued a public statement confirming that Martins did not enter the United States on the date in question. The agency described the record as erroneous, noted that it contradicted claims advanced by Brazilian Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes, and said the inaccurate entry remained under investigation. CBP explicitly condemned any misuse of the false record to support imprisonment.
During a March 5, 2026 hearing, Judge Presnell treated the entry as false. According to the hearing transcript, which later became public, he stated that a false record had been entered into Border Patrol systems, that the U.S. government acknowledged its falsity and gravity, and that the individual harmed by it had a right to know how the record was created and who was responsible. The judge ordered expanded searches of internal communications and criticized aspects of the government’s resistance to fuller disclosure.
As of mid-November 2026, the case remains active. Summary judgment briefing concluded in late October. No final order has been entered. On November 17, one of Martins’ Brazilian lawyers, Ricardo Scheiffer, stated that the U.S. proceedings are in their final stage and that a judicial decision is expected in the coming days. He said the anticipated ruling could authorize disclosure of the names of those involved in the false record, along with related internal materials. Scheiffer also noted that CBP had attempted contact seeking some form of agreement, which the defense interprets as concern over the names becoming public. The defense has previously indicated it already possesses certain names and messages but remains constrained by the litigation from releasing them.
The false U.S. record primarily affected the 2024 preventive detention phase of the Brazilian proceedings. Martins was later convicted by the First Panel of Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court in December 2025 to 21 years in prison in the broader “coup plot” case and is currently serving that sentence. The ongoing U.S. FOIA case is focused specifically on the creation and handling of the erroneous entry record.
The outcome of the Florida litigation is expected to clarify how the inaccurate record entered official systems and whether further accountability measures follow.
#FilipeMartins #FOIA #CBP #USCourt #FalseRecord #MiddleDistrictFlorida #BrazilUS #RuleOfLaw


