Crime Pays: The Batista Brothers’ Corruption Comeback Under Lula’s Watch
By Hotspotnews
Brazil’s billionaire Batista brothers, Joesley and Wesley, are back in the spotlight, proving once again that in Brazil, crime pays handsomely. Through their holding company, J&F Investimentos SA, they’re negotiating to buy French utility EDF’s thermal power plant in Rio de Janeiro for up to 2 billion reais ($374 million). This move, still in early stages and managed by Bank of America, is just the latest in their aggressive expansion into the energy sector. But the real story isn’t their business acumen—it’s how they’ve dodged accountability for one of Brazil’s biggest corruption scandals, thriving under President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s complicit administration.
The Batistas built their fortune through JBS, the world’s largest meatpacking company, on a foundation of systemic corruption. Operation Car Wash, the landmark probe into Brazil’s political and corporate rot, exposed their scheme: they admitted to bribing over 1,800 politicians with roughly $150 million to secure favorable loans, contracts, and influence. Their targets included presidents, lawmakers, and officials across the spectrum, with allegations of $80 million funneled to Lula and his protégé Dilma Rousseff via offshore accounts. Joesley even recorded then-President Michel Temer discussing hush money for a jailed politician, a scandal that nearly collapsed the government.
The consequences were massive but fleeting. J&F and JBS faced a record $3.2 billion fine in Brazil, with the brothers personally slapped with $35 million each. In the U.S., J&F pleaded guilty under the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act for using bribe proceeds to fuel acquisitions like Pilgrim’s Pride, paying over $256 million in penalties plus $27 million to the SEC. They were arrested for insider trading after dumping JBS shares before the scandal broke, pocketing millions as the stock tanked. After serving months in prison and stepping down from leadership, their plea deals granted immunity in exchange for testimony that dragged down Brazil’s political class.
Yet, the Batistas have staged a shameless comeback. In 2023, a Supreme Court justice suspended a $2 billion fine, citing prosecutorial overreach, letting J&F off the hook. By 2024, the brothers were back on JBS’s board, and in 2025, the company listed on the NYSE, cementing their return to power. Now, through J&F’s energy arm, Âmbar Energia, they’re chasing deals like the EDF plant and others, capitalizing on Brazil’s booming power sector. These aren’t the moves of men humbled by justice—they’re the actions of untouchables who know the system is rigged in their favor.
Lula’s role in this is impossible to ignore. Despite JBS’s testimony accusing him of taking bribes during his earlier terms, he’s welcomed the Batistas with open arms. Public records show Lula attending JBS plant events, traveling with Wesley to Paris, and holding private meetings with ministers alongside the brothers—access that screams favoritism. His administration’s Controladoria-Geral da União is reportedly negotiating a new leniency deal with J&F into 2025, potentially softening the 2017 penalties. This is no coincidence. Lula’s government, rooted in the same Workers’ Party scandals exposed by Car Wash, has a history of cozying up to corrupt tycoons. State banks like BNDES once funneled billions in cheap loans to JBS for global expansion, fueled by bribes to officials.
Today, Lula’s policies, like the National Energy Transition Policy, are opening floodgates for investments in sectors like energy, where J&F is conveniently positioned. The lack of scrutiny on the Batistas’ past as they snap up strategic assets reeks of complicity. It’s a pattern conservatives have long decried: Brazil’s left shields its allies, prioritizing power and “national champions” over justice. The Batistas’ fines, often paid from their ill-gotten wealth, are mere slaps on the wrist. Their empire grows, now spanning meat, finance, and energy, while ordinary Brazilians bear the cost of a corrupted system—higher prices, distorted markets, and eroded trust.
This saga exposes Brazil’s broken moral core. The Batistas’ resurgence isn’t just a business story; it’s a damning indictment of a nation where elites buy their way out of accountability. Until Brazil enforces real reforms—cutting the umbilical cord between corrupt tycoons and enabling politicians—the cycle of scandal and comeback will continue, leaving the country’s future in the hands of those who’ve already betrayed it.
Source: Reuters