Close Menu

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from HOTSPOT ORLANDO NEWS about , politics, health, tourism and business.

    What's Hot

    Lula’s Declarations on Iran’s Nuclear Program Are Irresponsible

    17 de November de 2026

    Flávio Dino’s Path from Militant to Court: Bias, Loyalty, and the Pursuit of Opponents

    17 de November de 2026

    Alcolumbre’s Reelection Threatens to Bury Major Scandals, Vieira Warns

    17 de November de 2026
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    HotspotOrlandoNewsHotspotOrlandoNews
    • Home
    • Brazil
    • Business
    • Politics
      1. Elections
      2. View All

      Brazil: Cutting Brasília, Not the Brazilian People Says Daniella

      15 de October de 2026

      Lula’s Economic Mismanagement Triggers Record Wave of Brazilian Business Failures

      28 de March de 2026

      Flávio Bolsonaro’s Uncompromising Vision. Cleaning up Lula’s mess

      10 de March de 2026

      Record R$1 Trillion Interest Payments Expose Lula’s Spending Spree

      31 de January de 2026

      Flávio Dino’s Path from Militant to Court: Bias, Loyalty, and the Pursuit of Opponents

      17 de November de 2026

      Internal Conflicts and Institutional Friction Threaten to Stall Banco Master Investigation

      13 de November de 2026

      Alcolumbre’s Fiscal Claims Don’t Match Reality

      13 de November de 2026

      Brazil-U.S. Tensions Under Lula and Trump: Documented Disagreements as of November 2026

      13 de November de 2026
    • Economy

      THE NUMBERS DON’T LIE OR HIDE LULA’S INCOMPETENCE

      21 de October de 2026

      Brazil: Cutting Brasília, Not the Brazilian People Says Daniella

      15 de October de 2026

      When Businesses Sink: Comparing Brazil’s Last Two Administrations

      29 de August de 2026

      Brazil’s Deepening Ties with Iran Collide with Trump’s Economic D-Day

      20 de August de 2026

      Brazil’s Debt Explosion: Lula’s Third Term Leaves a Fiscal Wreck

      17 de August de 2026
    • Tech
    • Behavior
    • USA
    • World
    • Summit 2026
    HotspotOrlandoNewsHotspotOrlandoNews
    Home » Mendonça Draws a Line: Restraint, Ethics, and the Limits of Judicial Activism
    Behavior

    Mendonça Draws a Line: Restraint, Ethics, and the Limits of Judicial Activism

    HotspotorlandoNewsBy HotspotorlandoNews17 de September de 2026Updated:17 de September de 2026No Comments3 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Mendonça Draws a Line: Restraint, Ethics, and the Limits of Judicial Activism

    By Hotspotnews

    Brazil’s Supreme Court once again exposed its internal fractures this week when Justice André Mendonça issued a formal note responding to public criticism from Justice Gilmar Mendes. The exchange, centered on the Banco Master investigation, is not merely a personal spat. It is a clash between two visions of the judiciary: one that treats the court as a political stage and another that insists on legal limits, institutional decorum, and equal application of rules.

    Mendonça’s cabinet began with the statute itself. Article 36, item III of Complementary Law 35/1979, the Organic Law of the National Magistrature, forbids a judge from publicly commenting on a pending case or issuing depreciative judgments about other judicial decisions. Mendes chose to ignore that prohibition and take the dispute to social media. Mendonça answered in writing, through official channels.

     

    The core factual point is straightforward. “The pretension of lifting secrecy of every and any procedure, without exception, did not come from the rapporteur,” the note states. “It came from those who today claim to be indignant with the publicity of the records.” Mendonça lifted secrecy only on a specific proceeding, in a reasoned decision within the limits of his authority. The broader demand for total transparency originated with the same critic now complaining about exposure.

    That inconsistency is not incidental. Mendes has long advocated unrestricted publicity of investigations. When the same principle began to affect conversations that embarrassed figures aligned with a different judicial faction, the outrage appeared. Mendonça noted the timing: the sudden concern for “exposure of others” emerged only after access was granted to a suspect’s cellphone and after press leaks that, coincidentally, targeted ministers who held dissenting views.

    The note also rejects any suggestion of complicity with leaks. Mendonça ordered investigations into every improper disclosure during the inquiry, including a specific phase examining possible involvement by a Federal Police official. There was no wink at selective leaking. There was an official demand for accountability.

    Mendonça further rejected the accusation that he used the court as a political platform. “The rapporteur never threatened anyone with public execration, nor used improper language to force anyone to withdraw from a judgment. He did not turn the plenary into a soapbox or circus, shouting to mask legally baseless insinuations.” Divergence among justices is legitimate in a collegial court. What is illegitimate is the attempt to constrain the judge through public pressure and insinuation.

    The deeper institutional warning is the call for an ethics code. Episodes like this, the note argues, demonstrate the urgency of rules that govern how justices speak both inside and outside the court, including in dealings with their peers. Verbosity, Mendonça observed, does not produce public confidence. It produces the opposite.

    The closing line is the most important. The Supreme Federal Court does not belong to any of its members. Respect is owed first to the institution, the Republic’s norms, and the liturgy of the office. When those standards are treated as optional, the court ceases to function as a court and begins to function as a factional arena.

    Source: Official note issued by the cabinet of Justice André Mendonça on September 17, 2026, in response to public comments by Justice Gilmar Mendes concerning the Banco Master investigation. Legal reference: Complementary Law 35/1979 (LOMAN), Article 36, III.

    #STF #AndréMendonça #ÉticaJudicial #EstadoDeDireito #GilmarMendes #JustiçaComLimites #DecoroInstitucional

    Andre Mendonça
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    HotspotorlandoNews
    • Website
    • Facebook
    • X (Twitter)
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn

    Related Posts

    Lula’s Declarations on Iran’s Nuclear Program Are Irresponsible

    17 de November de 2026

    Alcolumbre’s Reelection Threatens to Bury Major Scandals, Vieira Warns

    17 de November de 2026

    Flávio Bolsonaro warns that Brazil is becoming a narco-state

    16 de November de 2026
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Our Picks

    USA:Trump, in First Post-Midterm 60 Minutes Interview

    9 de November de 2026

    Shakira in Rio: the biggest party of the year

    3 de May de 2026

    Lula is Desperate and Panics as Flávio Bolsonaro Surges to Victory

    15 de April de 2026

    The Storm Brewing in Brasília: Vorcaro’s Imminent Confession and the Elite’s Panic

    21 de March de 2026
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • Vimeo
    Don't Miss

    Lula’s Declarations on Iran’s Nuclear Program Are Irresponsible

    Brazil 17 de November de 2026

    Lula’s Declarations on Iran’s Nuclear Program Are Irresponsible By Hotspotnews A president does not…

    Flávio Dino’s Path from Militant to Court: Bias, Loyalty, and the Pursuit of Opponents

    17 de November de 2026

    Alcolumbre’s Reelection Threatens to Bury Major Scandals, Vieira Warns

    17 de November de 2026

    Flávio Bolsonaro warns that Brazil is becoming a narco-state

    16 de November de 2026

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from SmartMag about art & design.

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    • Home
    • Brazil
    • Business
    • Financial
    • Education
    • Elections
    • ECONOMY
    • Media & Culture
    • Events
    • Lifestyle
    • Politics
    • Sports
    • LOCAL
    • Gastronomy
    • USA
    • World
    Grupo CALONE® Todos os direitos reservados. DBIPro© Copyright 2026.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.